Fear and loathing in Karachi

Published Apr 16, 2013 01:01am

Photo shows former Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto moments before she was assassinated at Rawalpindi’s Liaquat Bagh.—File Photo

Minutes before sunset on Dec 27, 2007, television channels started airing news of the assassination of former prime minister Benazir Bhutto in Rawalpindi.

And minutes after, Pakistan’s democratic and political future plunged into darkness: what about the elections scheduled for Jan 8? The end of a dictator’s rule? The integrity of Pakistan?

The answers started coming in slowly over the days that followed. Elections were delayed to Feb 18, retired Gen Pervez Musharraf emerged more powerful and Asif Ali Zardari, after taking over party affairs, insisted “Pakistan khappay (required)”, brushing aside fears of disintegration.

But the blood and violence that was sparked off in Sindh in particular remained a mystery. Was it a spontaneous reaction to the killing of the Pakistan’s twice-elected prime minister or a planned move to postpone the elections? Five years on, we remain unaware.

After coming into power, the PPP did set up a commission tasked to investigate the magnitude of the losses due to that bout of violence, discover the motives and trace the people responsible, but it failed to expose any of the facts. The commission was dissolved in less than a week without an explanation.

The financial capital of the country suffered most. Karachi descended into anarchy with fear ruling the city for almost a week; more than 30 people were killed in random violent episodes and hundreds of vehicles as well as business facilities were set ablaze. The level of brutality can be gauged by the fact that nearly half a dozen of people who died were labourers burnt to death inside an industrial unit in the Korangi area when it was set on fire by an ‘angry mob’.

Political parties’ election campaigns that had come to a halt amid the violence later gathered momentum again. But the challenges were far from over.

The city and the country went to the polls on Feb 18 with major contesting parties expressing misgivings about fair elections and a question mark over the voters’ list; the polling cards Karachiites got from different political parties revealed astonishing mistakes.

Polling day came to an end largely peacefully, with a 44 per cent voter turnout. The two main opposition parties, the PPP and the PML-N, won the majority of the seats and in Karachi the MQM retained all its seats as well as won constituencies where it had lost in the 2002 elections. The PPP was seen forming a government, but in coalition with other parties. A number of PPP candidates alleged massive rigging on certain Karachi seats, which dimmed the prospects of it allying with the MQM.

Along with a colleague and the correspondent of a foreign radio service, I witnessed the furious reaction of a senior PPP Karachi leader on the evening of Feb 18, when he was sure of having lost to his rival candidate on a National Assembly seat in district east. After recording a nearly five-minute sound bite regarding his reaction to the overall polling process in Karachi, the radio correspondent requested him to be “soft” as the words he was using could not be aired. The PPP leader, who later became a senator, refused, saying that the reality of polling day had been much harsher.

Yet the coming days witnessed a fade-out of the divisions between the PPP and MQM, and the two became strong ruling partners in both the centre and in Sindh. The relationship lasted almost five years, though with more lows than highs. The comments made by the PPP leader that Feb 18 evening still echo in my ears.

“After so much has happened today, if we still compromise only for the sake of power, then it would be the last five years,” he had said. “The PPP is an ideology and it will not sacrifice its half-a-century-old history over five years of government. After five years, we would not be able to face our own people.”


Do you have information you wish to share with Dawn.com? You can email our News Desk to share news tips, reports and general feedback. You can also email the Blog Desk if you have an opinion or narrative to share, or reach out to the Special Projects Desk to send us your Photos, or Videos.

More From This Section

PIA posts Rs10.1bn loss

Although deep in deficit, the loss decreased by 45pc from Rs18.4bn suffered in the corresponding six months of 2013.

Comments (3) (Closed)


Adnan
Apr 16, 2013 03:44pm
PPP has a lot more to be embarrassed about!
Razzaq
Apr 16, 2013 09:44pm
The guilty will never tell the truth as to why Karachi was targeted for burning, looting and killing while the PPP leader was killed in Rawalpindi nothing of that sort took place in any Punjab city. Simply it was a known reaction from the elements who could not approve the progress and developments done in Karachi.
khan
Apr 16, 2013 11:14pm
But Again for sake of Power, PPP would joing MQM again....if not now then next elections..