“Poverty has a woman’s Face”

Published Apr 14, 2013 10:00am

pakistan-feminisation-poverty-1

Hajra, Khatija and Sakina: three friends and neighbours living in Karachi’s Lyari area. Hajra lives alone with her three daughters: her husband left her when the youngest child was merely six months old, because she couldn’t give birth to a son. Khatija’s husband is as good as absent: he’s a drug addict. Survival, with a little daughter and a son, is one terrifying day after another. She lives in dread that her son may adopt the same path as his father. Sakina is divorced, without support from her former husband. She continues working to support her children; they’re not yet at the age where they could start earning a living.

Hajra and her friends are just a few of the millions of Pakistani women whose lives are constrained by extreme poverty. Studies, and even just observation, frequently highlight women’s disproportionately high representation among the country’s poor. As Dr Mahbub ul Haq once put it, “Women have been reduced to economic nonentities.”

Globally, poverty remains a challenge: the World Bank estimates that 1.29 billion people live in absolute poverty; the sad fact is that about 70 per cent of them are women. In Pakistan, it is no different, but without a national census, it isn’t even possible to gauge the correct picture. Poverty is difficult to quantify: the methodology used by the government has been challenged by the World Bank and the UNDP, while independent organisations consider poverty to be above 28.3pc.

However, according to the Human Development Index, 2009, 60.3pc of Pakistan’s population lives on $2 per day. According to Unesco, 71pc of eligible girls did not attend secondary school in 2009. Gender discriminatory practices shape poverty: as expected, more women are at the suffering end. They suffer poverty of opportunities far more than men. Poverty gives rise to social powerlessness and political disenfranchisement, and these add to the vulnerability of the poor.

The reasons for such high poverty levels are several: corruption, illicit capital flight, debt and loan conditionalities, high defence expenditures, and now, extremism. Those are the general ones.

To quote Tahira Abdullah, “Poverty has a woman’s face.” Women face the triple burden of child-bearing, child rearing, and domestic unpaid labour; they have been denied opportunities for growth, are without access to adequate healthcare, education or income, and simultaneously forced to live in the tight bind of culture and tradition.

Their poverty is multidimensional; not only of lack of income, but also of nutrition and health; they are denied education and the ability to earn an adequate income, their vulnerability prevents them from advancing their innate capabilities. To add to that, gender biases and patriarchal/misogynist mindsets permeate every aspect of their lives. Living with discrimination and gender-based violence is a daily reality for many.

Poverty levels in the country have crept upwards and are considered to be among the highest in South Asia. Unfortunately, the Planning Commission does not reveal the exact data on female poverty. Women bear the brunt of appallingly high socio-economic disparities; their poverty extends from the small and large denials within the home to the wider denials they experience in the community. Often they’re not even recognised as heads of households; their labour in the agricultural sector is largely unremunerated; they remain exploited, deprived of income.

The Economic Survey of Pakistan barely acknowledges their presence and their contribution — the female labour force participation rate is the lowest in the South Asian region. A survey by Yasir Amin (in Economistan, April 12, 2012) noted that women’s contribution to the labour force had actually shrunk from 33pc in 2000 to 21pc in 2011.

The risks of increasing poverty grow in parallel with the number of women-headed households. Single mothers are at highest risk, as are their children, who are likely to be deprived of adequate schooling and nutrition. Like most women, they have no alternative to poorly paid, informal employment.

It is no surprise that women are over-represented among the country’s poor; discrimination against them exists at all levels, within the family, with its unequal gendered division of responsibilities and labour, inequality in access to healthcare, to schooling, to social protection. Tradition ordains that their mobility be restricted.

Unsurprisingly, few poor women have hope of escaping this poverty as there are so many odds stacked against them. Despite laws that favour them, even richer women are regularly denied land inheritance by emotional coercion, forced marriage and even by ‘marriage’ to the Quran.

The current political situation prevailing in the country presents a mixed picture for women’s progress and development. On the one hand, there are several forward-looking laws and amendments, widespread provision of safety nets like the Benazir Income Support Programme and increased school enrolment for girls. On the other hand is the snail’s pace at which the bureaucracy moves to implement those laws. Then again, there’s society’s stubbornly ‘eyes shut’ attitude to women’s rights and progress, the lack of recognition that women’s progress requires an acceptance of their constitutionally guaranteed equal status as citizens of this country.

If women are to progress and participate effectively in the economy, they must receive equal education, equal training, in rural and urban sectors and equal dignity and income. Pakistan cannot achieve progress on the efforts of less than half its population.


Do you have information you wish to share with Dawn.com? You can email our News Desk to share news tips, reports and general feedback. You can also email the Blog Desk if you have an opinion or narrative to share, or reach out to the Special Projects Desk to send us your Photos, or Videos.

More From This Section

Comments (11) Closed




Indicus
Apr 14, 2013 02:51pm
Women are worst sufferers where Islam is implemented in letter and spirit.
TheFartman (@abduinmarkets)
Apr 14, 2013 06:44pm
So poor yet so many children. What the hell is wrong with these people? Why do they take so much pride in raising as many children they can just because 'naslan' chalana ha? Whats about putting all their resources into one child?? I will never understand this rural primitive people. All they know is sleep, feed, protest and breed.
Hira
Apr 15, 2013 12:19am
When did women, rural or urban ever have rights to their reproduction??? That remains either in the hands of their bored husbands or sadly their mother in law...
Farhan
Apr 14, 2013 10:02am
an overhaul of the ethics nd religious values may be solution to many problems
Ghazal
Apr 14, 2013 04:44pm
These women actually serve to increase class-based gender inequality in Pakistan. These women, like the politically powerful women in South Africa, have done precious little for women living in poverty.
Shahid Khan
Apr 14, 2013 11:35pm
That sounds like hot air.
Ravi Ingale from University of Pune.
Apr 14, 2013 05:29am
Those picture shown in this article, anybody can guess that all the women are Hindus but they are in Pakistan so they are the Muslims. Sometime before Dawn wrote an article on "Decline of Muslims in India" Muslim in India are 400% more than 1947 time. What about Hindus in Pakistan?? those were 19% in 1947, now they are just 0.24%??? Dawn will never put such data and Article in their web page.
Palvasha von Hassell
Apr 14, 2013 01:32pm
Such a good thing to highlight the plight of women, and the manifold injustices to which society subjects them. Can anyone tell me if there is any micro-finance scheme in place, or welfare organisations which can reliably reach out to such women? For Pakistan really needs women's development, without which no progress will be worth the name.
Amir
Apr 14, 2013 11:58am
Excellent article, thought provoking and terrifying. Do anybody in Pakistan care about poverty among masses of people in general and female workers in particular. Do these people always remain poor and the high-ups will keep on stealing public money by passing acts and regulations to benefit themselves for life. One of my professors did a major research on female participation in the labor force of Pakistan (she now teaches at a university in USA) and concluded that women are not even considered part of the labor force Planning Commission. Women are also facing hiring and wage discrimination across the country. Please let us support our sisters, mothers, wives, and daughters to become an integral part of the society.
Jalbani Baloch
Apr 14, 2013 08:53am
Women are the most sufferer segment of the society. They are facing all kinds of problems at all levels and in all conditions of their existence, whether be housewives, on-farm workers, office-workers, or as mothers, wives, sisters and etc. The problem is that the men consider themselves as masters and them as subjects. This state of affairs, is the continuity of pre-Islamic period, which only saw a relief of explitation in the early days of Islam. The condition of women is general in nature in all countries including the women living in western world. The best way to restore the dignity of women in Pakistan is to implement Islam in letter and spirit in all affairs of our lives.
msm
Apr 14, 2013 10:36am
What about Hina Rabbani Khar, BB, Faryal Talpur, Nilofar Bakhtiar, Naheed Khan, Fehmida Mirza, Nasreen Jalil and so many others? are they not women or do they not have a woman's face?