PAF: discipline and equality

Published Mar 30, 2013 04:07am

This refers to the letter by Wing Commander (r) Ahmed Shah Jan (March 27). The writer, I believe, has been my worthy colleague at the PAF Academy, Risalpur.

An English teacher by profession, he writes well. But on this occasion I have not been able to understand what cavil he had at my letter on the subject (March 11), when he said “a foot soldier should be getting twice as much as an army officer because his chances of dying in a war are far greater than officers performing non-active and risk-free roles”.

The comparison appears odious. It is not only the extent of exposure to risk but the substantive value of the life lost.

As regards the numbers, foot soldiers are employed in far greater numbers in a war than army officers, hence their casualties are more.

So what is the catch? But the disparity in the pay and perks between an officer and a foot soldier in the context of the army and more particularly in the context of PAF between a pilot and a ground officer or airmen in the context of PAF is not only due to the risk factor but also due to the element of demand and supply.

Look at the rate of attrition of pilots. From the time they report for training to the time they become senior officers, a large number of them either perish or grounded or otherwise eliminated.

An operational pilot is, therefore, not only highly skilled but hard to come by, like gold dust. This explains the disparity between a ground branch officer and a pilot.

However, it is true that the disparity in other service matters is at times unnecessarily stretched too far to the chagrin of the ground branch officer. But this requires a separate discussion.

Group Capt (r) S.M. ANWAR Karachi


Do you have information you wish to share with Dawn.com? You can email our News Desk to share news tips, reports and general feedback. You can also email the Blog Desk if you have an opinion or narrative to share, or reach out to the Special Projects Desk to send us your Photos, or Videos.

More From This Section

Medium of instruction

PROFESSOR (Dr) Arifa Farid’s letter ‘Medium of instruction’ (Nov 21) is a welcome breeze in a desert. Our...

Traffic solution

Living in cities and towns, we daily face the horror that traffic has become. Youngters riding motorcycles in a...

Comments (3) Closed




Maverick
Mar 30, 2013 06:41am
Please explain to me why GD(P) pilots in UAV squadrons are still getting the flying allowance and please do not say that flying a UAV is a very difficult and a dangerous job. Also please explain when an officer from the GD(P) branch reaches the rank of Gp Capt his days of flying mostly end so explain to me when Gp Capt to ACM does not fly then why they still get the flying allowance.
Tahir
Mar 30, 2013 09:42am
I am ashamed to read about this rivalry between our fighting forces for the sake of security of the country. This, rivalry, differences in status and looking down on others is like cancer which is preventing us from making progress in all walks of our lives. Can we just drop this subject and not bring ourselves so low as to have it published in a national newspaper.
Fahad
Mar 31, 2013 04:55am
I hate to see such corruption in the armed forces. Petty bickering over allowances. I thought that was the domain of the civil servants. Apparently not. Let's end this once and for all and establish equality in pay between pilots and ground officers of the same rank.