Behind the times: Property laws

Published Mar 22, 2013 05:05am

WHAT remains of the Margalla Towers, which partially collapsed during the 2005 earthquake, has been a grim feature of Islamabad’s landscape for years. As court battles continued over the fixing of blame, Islamabad’s residents became accustomed to the ruin looming over one of the main residential arteries. But compensation issues having largely been settled some time ago, on Wednesday the process of demolishing the building was finally initiated by a private firm that has purchased the site and been granted permission by the Capital Development Authority. Soon, evidence of perhaps the worst such episode seen in the capital will have been erased from sight.

In the case of Margalla Towers, apartment owners were paid compensation because of suspicions that the structure had been improperly constructed. But the case should be taken as a wake-up call for the manner in which the country’s legislation on property has not kept up with changing urban development patterns and lifestyle choices. Though apartment buildings are now a decades-old feature of our cities, Karachi in particular, the laws and by-laws that apply in case of disputes or disasters are scattered and piecemeal, and out of touch with new realities. Simply put, the owner of a house damaged or destroyed by an occurrence for which the state or builder cannot be held responsible — a natural disaster, terrorism or a riot, for example — and where, therefore, a civil suit for damages does not apply, still has the land as an asset. But apartment owners of a compromised building do not have that. Even the eventual sale of the plot and division of funds — which would require full agreement of all owners, a difficult task to achieve — would be a fraction of the value of the asset lost. In a country where violence is a daily reality and its effect on infrastructure inevitable in several cases, these gaps in property legislation need to be urgently addressed. Further, home insurance needs to be popularised and made more accessible.


Do you have information you wish to share with Dawn.com? You can email our News Desk to share news tips, reports and general feedback. You can also email the Blog Desk if you have an opinion or narrative to share, or reach out to the Special Projects Desk to send us your Photos, or Videos.

More From This Section

Simply democracy

Almost dictators in Pakistan adopted the flawed opinion in past that "Western democracy does not suit Pakistan."

Promoting tolerance

The issue of violence against minorities is of grave intensity, it requires some immediate steps to be halt.

Thar reality check

Sindh government will have to provide potable water and other basic facilities to Thar, so as to reduces its woes.

Comments (2) Closed




Shahid Bajwa
Mar 22, 2013 01:45pm
Congrats on raising this very relevant issue. I have been discussing it with property agents and lawyer friends and nobody is clear on the final distribution of assets when the apartment block needs to be demolished/re-constructed due to accident or natural wear and tear. Karachi and Islamabad are particularly affected, so can their local authorities make some clear rules?
Qulik
Mar 23, 2013 12:27am
what what what -what!