Dangerous precedent

Published Feb 12, 2013 12:03am

ON Jan 16, Dawn reported that the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa government had placed the employees of Pakistan Railways under the provincial labour department by repealing the federal ‘Payment of Wages Act, 1936’, as it believed it had the right after the 18 Amendment.

This is an astonishing development, as not only have workers of a federal entity been placed under provincial laws but the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa government has also unilaterally repealed a federal law.

This reminds us of the constitutional crisis that took place in the US when the state of North Carolina unilaterally annulled the federal ‘tariff of 1828’ bill, which ultimately became a harbinger for the US civil war. Fortunately, this action by the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa government has not resulted in any such reaction here in Pakistan, but it sets a dangerous precedent.

What if Sindh tomorrow unilaterally repeals the federal PCB Ordinance and sets up its own cricket board to play international cricket?

Furthermore, if every province sets up its own labour laws and codes, it will become prohibitively expensive and messy to do business in Pakistan, as companies with employees in more than one province would have to hire an army of lawyers and accountants just to stay on top of the mishmash of provincial laws.

The 18th Amendment seems to have created more problems for the federation than solving them; enough of this devolution and autonomy nonsense.

The architects of the 18th Amendment should have compared their draft with the constitutions of other federations before finalising it.

All federations of the world have a single set of labour laws for national companies within their borders, and the federation of Pakistan should be no exception.

ZAFAR CHEEMA United Kingdom


Do you have information you wish to share with Dawn.com? You can email our News Desk to share news tips, reports and general feedback. You can also email the Blog Desk if you have an opinion or narrative to share, or reach out to the Special Projects Desk to send us your Photos, or Videos.

More From This Section

Post-America Afghanistan

IN 2006 the US Geological Survey and the UK Geological Survey carried out extensive airborne magnetic, gravity and...

Ebola in Pakistan

IT HAS been almost two months since the ministry of health issued the warning on Ebola in Pakistan and now one...

The Indian peasant

IMRAN Khan is always telling the audience in his public addresses that the peasants in India enjoy special...

Comments (1) Closed




mohammad shafique
Feb 12, 2013 05:20pm
pakistan should never have been a federation. the federal set up has been imposed on pakistan by decades of army rule pakistan should have been a confederation as envisaged in the lahore resolution of 1940