DR Tahirul Qadri’s long march ended on a dubious note, raising as many questions as were raised at its start. However, the long march did give a few loud and clear messages to the nation.

First, the reasonably large crowd, including women and infants, who braved the frigid cold of Islamabad for four days and nights, gave a loud message to the rulers as to how miserable the lives of ordinary people had become under this government.

Second, Dr Qadri’s focus on electoral reforms again highlighted the fact that democracy in Pakistan had effectively been reduced to a plutocracy as no middle class person could ever hope to get elected to assemblies because of the millions of rupees required for contesting elections.

Third, legislation favouring major political parties was done quickly whereas pro-people legislation such as the anti-terrorism bill and the accountability bill could not be finalised even in five years.

Last, it was interesting to see how parties representing the old order or status quo forgot their differences and got together against a force which was beginning to exert pressure on its weak underbelly.


Puppet show NATIONS prone to religious manipulation have been fed falsehood since ages. This is not new. For a religious leader it is not hard to gather a large group of revolution-seeking citizens.

Dr Tahirul Qadri’s march was not far-off either. His call for a revolution was a mere attention-seeking feat.

A revolution is an ongoing process which involves social, economic, political and religious stability. I cannot just gather a number of students from different branches of my school and take them to the capital to make certain demands. I do not hesitate to declare that it was just another puppet show.


Fake revolution PAKISTANIS are quite used to adulteration in everything. We have phony religious leaders, quacks, spurious medicines, businessmen, democrats and dictators. People know all this and yet believe them. Now we have made a joke of the term revolution. Now we also have a fake revolution.

Dr Tahirul Qadri made fiery speeches and talked about issues being faced by the nation. Nobody could disagree with what he said in his speeches.

The people followed his long march and faced cold weather in the hope of achieving what the Canadian scholar had claimed to gain. But the way this caravan ended its march for revolution has made revolution a joke.I feel sorry for the innocent people whose religious and national emotions were exploited. The slogan ‘revolution’ has lost its significance in Pakistan. It seems we will never have anything real in this country.

PROF M. ISHAQ     Karachi

Do you have information you wish to share with Dawn.com? You can email our News Desk to share news tips, reports and general feedback. You can also email the Blog Desk if you have an opinion or narrative to share, or reach out to the Special Projects Desk to send us your Photos, or Videos.

More From This Section

Are sit-ins democratic?

NOW that sit-ins have ended, it’s time to discuss this phenomenon in terms of a democratic device to put pressure...

Wildlife conservation

A SAYING goes that one can measure the greatness and moral progress of a nation by monitoring its treatment of...

Why ban pillion-riding?

THE Sindh government’s latest effort and strategy to ostensibly curb rising street crimes and targeted killings in...

Comments (1) Closed

Syed Ahmed
Jan 28, 2013 03:47am
Short of instigating a bloody revolution Dr. Qadri has awaken common people. Most of his demands are legitimate and in favour of the people, such as seizure of discretionary funds of the Prime Minister and Chief Ministers. Reconstitutions of the Election Commission since its four members have not been selected strictly according to the provisions of the constitution.