Prof Rauf Parekh’s column (Nov 5) reminds me of an event of the early 1960s. Immediately after doing my MA, I joined the Philosophy Department of Karachi University as a lecturer.

Dr Ishtiaque Hussain Quraishi was then the vice-chancellor. I was teaching BA (Hons) courses. In one of the courses I set the question paper, and was examining the answer sheets.

One of my students was a native Scot who was perhaps Dr Quraishi’s adopted son.

As I started reading his answer sheet, I realised that the student’s script was absolutely illegible. I showed it the chairperson of the department and to other senior colleagues.

They all agreed that it was not possible to read his handwriting. The chairperson forwarded the matter to the examination department. Arrangements were made to send the boy to my office so that he could read out the answers and I would then award him marks. It was indeed a very embarrassing situation for this student.

Next year I set the examination paper of Ethics. One of the questions was, ‘Explain the Retributive theory of Punishment: an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth’.

The British boy left the entire paper unanswered except one. He wrote:

“An eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth, and a foot for a foot; my foot!” Perhaps after this event he left Pakistan and went back to his native land.

On my part he provided me an occasion for a very hearty laughter not only for that moment but for whenever I recall the event.

PROF (Rtd) DR ARIFA FARID Karachi

Updated Jan 08, 2013 12:05am

More From This Section

PPO’s implications

The Protection of Pakistan Ordinance (PPO) grants sweeping powers of arrest and detention to security forces. We ...

Intolerant society

A NUMBER of incidents during the last couple of weeks have shattered the peace of my mind. One was a gang-rape...

Drug abuse

THE surfacing of drug-abuse statistics in Pakistan by Drug Use in Pakistan, 2013, has shocked legal and medical...

Retirees’ appointment

APROPOS your news report, “Retirees` reappointment goes against SC orders” (April 13), by reappointing retired...

Security guards

I HAVE read with interest your editorial “Security guards’ plight” (April 14). I compliment Dawn for raising...

Comments (3) (Closed)


Dr Khan
Jan 08, 2013 07:03pm
I am laughing. Thanks for sharing your laughter with us.
Agha Ata (USA)
Jan 08, 2013 01:47pm
Reminds me of Mahatma Gandhi when he was asked a similar question he said, "'An eye for an eye' would leave the whole world blind."
Javed
Jan 09, 2013 03:50am
How mundane can it get.