HOW can there be any justification of this amnesty, because the majority of Pakistanis pay their direct and indirect taxes? How can they appreciate amnesty for those who have continuously violated the laws of the country and desisted from paying any taxes or at best paid paltry sums, while they have accumulated wealth beyond imagination.

How can anyone justify the payment of 8/10th of one per cent tax on five million rupees, or one per cent if paid next month, or 1.4 per cent the following month on this sum?

Is this democracy when our elected representatives want to make laws that favour the already favoured?

This Amnesty Bill is othing but a reward for those who have accumulated wealth so they can ‘whiten’ such money. Any MNA who votes in favour of this bill will be failing in his duty to the people he represents, besides being answerable to his Creator in the final analysis.

It has also been reported that the members of the Senate and the National Assembly have voiced their anger at news reports showing how little, if any, tax they have paid and violated laws by not submitting annual tax returns. What these ‘learned’ individuals, who call themselves representatives of the people, should have done is to publish proof of payment of taxes and copies of tax returns. Alternatively, they could have asked the FBR to make public their tax returns so the people would see for themselves. They must know that even the president of the United States makes public his annual tax return.

If democracy means government of the people, by the people and for the people, then let all benefits accrue to the people -- all people, not just the elite or those who happen to govern us.

M. HASAN     Karachi

Updated Dec 28, 2012 03:05am

More From This Section

PPO’s implications

The Protection of Pakistan Ordinance (PPO) grants sweeping powers of arrest and detention to security forces. We ...

Intolerant society

A NUMBER of incidents during the last couple of weeks have shattered the peace of my mind. One was a gang-rape...

Drug abuse

THE surfacing of drug-abuse statistics in Pakistan by Drug Use in Pakistan, 2013, has shocked legal and medical...

Retirees’ appointment

APROPOS your news report, “Retirees` reappointment goes against SC orders” (April 13), by reappointing retired...

Security guards

I HAVE read with interest your editorial “Security guards’ plight” (April 14). I compliment Dawn for raising...

Comments (Closed)


Syed Ahmed
Dec 28, 2012 05:25pm
In fact the evasion of Taxes is nothing new. During second Benazir?s government my friend, an ENT specialist (Colonel) in PNS Shifa had a chart inserted under the glass top of his desk that listed Annual Tax paid by the PM and her top Ministers whose sum total could not even match the amount paid by the Colonel himself. It is time to haul the Tax evaders, their properties be annexed and later auctioned to recover the stolen amount.