Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


Far from the circus


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

THE contortions of leaders as the deadly cut and thrust of politics plays out in Pakistan could easily lead an observer to believe that, as in some Machiavellian court, the be all and end all is power. But as the circus of politics goes from one impossible feat to the next, from time to time stories — usually tragedies — make their way through the headlines about ousted prime ministers and clashing institutions to raise the issue of silent sufferers whose welfare is almost an afterthought for the state. Last week, Pakistanis learnt to their horror that an ineffective labour-inspection system corroded by powerful groups with vested interests had caused over 250 people to perish in circumstances that defy the imagination. Meanwhile, the rains have destroyed the lives and livelihoods of hundreds of thousands of people, particularly in Baloch-istan, southern Punjab and Sindh. In just two districts of Balochistan — Naseerabad and Jaffarabad — an estimated 600,000 people have been marooned.

Predictably, the state’s response has been to creakily roll out rescue efforts after the damage has already been done. Can the state administration say with honesty that everything possible was done pre-emptively to mitigate rain-related havoc? Given the experience of the past two years, the state ought to have been more prepared, particularly with regard to planned evacuations, camps for displaced people, rations stored against future needs and a coordinated rescue strategy. Instead, what we are witnessing, as usual, is different agencies — including the army, national and provincial-level disaster management cells, etc — doing what they can but generally appearing as though they’ve been caught napping.

For years, there have been warnings about the effects of climate change; Pakistan will undoubtedly be affected. This is the third consecutive year that the country has been hit by a destructive monsoon. The Met office is forecasting heavy rain over the week in the northern parts of the country, water that will make its way south. There is still time to plan for the coming deluge over the next weeks and months. Better mechanisms and systems need to be put in place urgently. Demonstrably, it is not enough to establish emergency response agencies unless these are equipped, trained and interested in fulfilling their mandate. In many countries, what has proved most effective is the involvement of local leadership and administrative mechanisms, with their on-the-ground knowledge and stakes in the welfare of an area. Is it too much to ask for politics to be put on hold and for political elites to come together to plan for the welfare of this country’s hapless millions?

Comments (5) Closed

chaudry Sep 18, 2012 09:46am
Can't they built dams to store water...and turn these deluge into useful resources for future usage.......
abbas kd Sep 18, 2012 03:07pm
Killings & slaughter of innocent humans in Karachi, deaths by floods all over Pakistan, Electricity cutts up to 20 hours daily, no health care or social services sytems in the country, & no train engines to run the trains in that country. Political leaders are busy fighting with the Judicial authorities instead of appologizing the nation for their criminal behaviour of stealing $60 millions. For some odd reasons, President Zardari thinks this nation will vote overwhelmingly in favor of his party again in the next election.
Haji Ashfaq Sep 18, 2012 07:51am
More than 90% readers of DAWN have replied in negative about the Disaster Management Authority's ability to handle the situation even if the country is facing it a consecutive third time. The Armed forces come to help only when requested by the Civil administration. Not their responsibility - however.So, its a clear failure of the Civilian authorities who are grossly corrupt. The relevations in Karachi Fire case is an example.
M. Asghar Sep 18, 2012 06:02am
Time and time again, we are pestered with " is it too much to ask for politics to be put on hold...."? knowing that there is no politics: the working of a state as an organised city, but only vested and Machiavellian manipulations for crude and feudal power, where the country, its people and their problems have no relevance. The result of this total disfunctionment of the state, we live everywhere in the horrendous suffering caused by the floods in different parts of the country and the murderous mayhem in Karachi and the corroding general lawlessness.
Ajaya K Dutt Sep 19, 2012 04:11am
It is done in southern california and there is a network of "wells" that feed and refresh the aquifer that streches hundreds and hundreds of miles, raising up water table which can be tapped during dry spell. Even India has done it in South India. It is very good idea.