Alert Sign Dear reader, online ads enable us to deliver the journalism you value. Please support us by taking a moment to turn off Adblock on

Alert Sign Dear reader, please upgrade to the latest version of IE to have a better reading experience


The award list


Your Name:

Recipient Email:

IN a list of 192 — the number of honours conferred by the Pakistani state on its landmark 65th birth anniversary — there are names which appear worthy of celebration. Saadat Hasan Manto is one. He is a happy-sad reminder of the progress Pakistan has made in over six decades of suppressed existence. He is a rebel who has not ceased to bring out irony long after his departure, and justifies the cliché about a person bringing honour to an award. And then Manto has not quite gotten over his habit of creating a little controversy. If he is the standard, other choices may suffer in comparison and a long argument on merit may ensue — who else should get the award and who should be made to wait a little longer to help the roll of honour retain or regain its brevity and prestige?

Medal choices, subjective as they are, are easier to defend in fields as open to interpretation as literature. Gallantry, often proven at the cost of life or grievous hurt to a person, is another area where the choice is easier to accept, sentiment being a vital ingredient that goes into the making of a medal. But there are still other selections from other areas which must walk to the hall of fame with their stature over-politicised. The present government loves to give out awards and has received its share of criticism for drawing heavily on the boxful of decorations reserved for its own people and allies. The president’s Aug 14 list again includes some well-known government functionaries among allies who could have perhaps been permitted a bit of modesty in office. As members of the award-giving authority, they are liable to appear to be blowing their own trumpet. Their biggest award must come not from the rulers but from the people.

Comments (4) Closed

M. Asghar Aug 16, 2012 09:17am
These awards lists are most of the time polluted with partisan interests, where merit does not have much value.
Taaruf Aug 16, 2012 12:10pm
This award exemplifies a system of personalized sympathy. It shows that political rulers are being awarded for doing nothing.
Haji Ashfaq Aug 16, 2012 07:44am
The award list is never short of "Joy riders".
Asif Ansari Aug 16, 2012 10:50pm
Medal gives to died Manto, good! but some of us know, when Manto lives, his life is full of sorrows and difficulties, no-body can help of such type of marvellous writer, when he pray for everybody to help him and his writing . Those read the Manto's books they decide well, whose type of person he is. If Manto lives today, he cannot be take medal such type of our current government. Manto is a man of words. Yes. 192, personalities has taken the medals, DAWN, rightly said the majority of person does not the ability for gaining these medal, but government decided, its must be happy to everybody with any cost. So good practice by the government side.