29 August, 2014 / Ziqa'ad 2, 1435

Making TB a notifiable disease

Published Jul 23, 2012 06:03pm

A new legislation is on the anvil to declare tuberculosis (TB) as a notifiable disease in Pakistan. When passed, the “Tuberculosis Notification Act, 2012” would make it mandatory on all registered medical and traditional practitioners, registered hakims, healthcare providers, pathological laboratories, educational institutions, industrial concerns, mines, jails, madrasas, refugee camps, councilors, tribal heads, maliks, lumbardars, appointed and hereditary community representatives to notify District EDO Health of a confirmed or suspected TB case in accordance with the set procedures.

Notification would be done either by sending TB Notification Form by registered post to the EDO Health, completing the appropriate TB Notification form on-line a website, or by telephoning on a universal access number. Failure to notify and breach of confidentiality of the TB patient would amount to a cognizable offence and be liable to penalty.

Such a policy has far reaching consequences for the health of almost every citizen and raises many questions. What does it mean for a disease to be notifiable? What ethical, programmatic and sociological aspects must be considered for its success? How would it affect the disease control programs on the ground?

It is not in scope of this space to answer these questions at length but I would like to underlines here that these, and indeed many other arising questions, need to be fully explored and discussed within the health, patients, communities and development circles. There clearly are rights issues involved in this debate and people involved in rights campaigns need to pay attention and get involved.

TB is a notifiable disease in most developed countries including Australia, Hong Kong, Malaysia, United Kingdom and United States. Recently, India has also declared it a notifiable disease. Some examples of other notifiable diseases in these and indeed in many other developed countries are cholera, leprosy, diphtheria, plague, tetnus, typhoid and yellow fever.

According to estimates some 420,000 new cases of TB occur in Pakistan every year, of which 15,000 are suffering from multi-drug resistant TB (MDR TB). However, only about 50% of the TB patients affected by the bacteria susceptible to be killed with the first line anti-TB drugs and a fraction of the MDR TB, which is much more expensive and difficult to treat disease, avail the free TB services at the government run TB facilities.

Making TB a notifiable disease would make it mandatory for the government to ensure equal and fair distribution of resources to treat all the patients for free whether reporting at the public or private health care services. This would mean that already dwindling resource allocation for TB treatment in the country just not be enough and the question of where the additional resources going to come makes this a tricky preposition.

Success of the new policy would depend largely on whether the required sensitive approach towards stakeholders, especially the patients, their families, and the communities where they live. The policy formulation and implementation needs to done in a way which ensures that a negative public health or social justice outcome is allowed to negate the gains to be made by the new policy as well as protect those made by TB control in the past years. One particular area to watch out for is that the mandatory notification may heighten the existing stigma and discrimination faced by TB patients. This will drive patients away making them to seek care much later or even disappear altogether from the radar.

I am highlighting this last point particularly so after having reviewed the recent Indian experience. The policy mandating TB notification in India was formulated without any dialogue with the stakeholders to ensure that the policy guarantees medical confidentiality of TB patients, provides for the necessary psychosocial support and access to the most appropriate treatment as per WHO guidelines. It is quite clear that there is need for an open and inclusive discussion and debate in Pakistan with all the stakeholders, including patients suffering from TB and its different forms, regarding the different aspects, benefits versus harms of the policy of compulsory notification of TB cases to the TB authorities.

As Shobha Shukla, and Bobby Ramakant of Citizen News Service very comprehensively put it: “Genuinely engaging affected communities in TB programs as equal partners with dignity, ensuring quality counseling in TB programs, improving treatment and health literacy, addressing TB related stigma and discrimination that still is rampant in our society, thinking beyond DOTS when it comes to treatment provision, integrating TB programs with other development programs such as those on nutrition, sanitation, harm reduction, HIV, diabetes, among others, monitoring irrational use of drugs, strengthening health systems, and many such measures will yield more sustainable and positive public health and social justice outcomes”.

Watch video blog in Urdu on 'Making TB a notifiable disease '


Ayyaz Kiani is a public health specialist. He heads Devnet – a network of development consultants. Based in Islamabad, he has travelled around the world and continues to do so to meet fellow travelers. He can be reached at ayyaz_kiani@hotmail.com.


The views expressed by this blogger and in the following reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Dawn Media Group.


Do you have information you wish to share with Dawn.com? You can email our News Desk to share news tips, reports and general feedback. You can also email the Blog Desk if you have an opinion or narrative to share, or reach out to the Special Projects Desk to send us your Photos, or Videos.

More From This Author

The medical fiasco

The incidence of over-treating people from asthma to breast cancer, from high blood pressure to low bone density is on a dramatic rise.

The Polio Conundrum

Failure to eradicate polio from the last remaining strongholds could result in as many as 200,000 new cases every year, within 10 years, all over the world.

Comments (6) (Closed)


NASAH (USA)
Jul 25, 2012 03:22pm
So in Pakistan TB is not a notifiable disease -- oh my God what a horrendous mistake -- in every civilized country TB is a notifiable disease even in India -- how come it is not in Pakistan?
imtiaz faruqui
Jul 23, 2012 03:08pm
Hepatitis can be prevented to a large degree by simply washing hands all around and most important between gingers after using the bathroom. Educate your children with this procedure.
Rashi
Jul 23, 2012 08:48am
The news is of good omen. The steps should also be taken to cope with Hepatitis, a hazardous disease spreading like wild fire when every third person in Pakistan is subject to it!
Cyrus Howell
Jul 23, 2012 07:07pm
The alternative is a lot of dead people.
aaa
Jul 23, 2012 07:49pm
Im not sure where you got your numbers but i think the number is more than 420 thousand an year. One major problem with TB is trying to explain patients that they need medicine for months. In TB ward patients stopped taking medicines after 2 months or so when they felt they were now symptomfri only to come back after a few months even worse. Education should be given on mass scale on television and media. Secondly dont know what the routine is but the worst patients i remember came from jails. What sort of routine they follow there is unknown to me.
NASAH (USA)
Aug 08, 2012 05:30pm
There are three types of Hepatitis A, B, C -- only one the A, the mildest one is spread through contaminated food and through eating raw oysters -- the other two are the deadly kind spread through sex and contaminated needles. Looks like in Pakistan there is no public health education.