No saints in this Multan

Published Jul 22, 2012 03:02am

PULL out your divining rod and put your ear to the ground, it’s time to figure out what Multan meant.

Gilani won; Bosan lost. That we know. But what does everyone else take away from it?

The trouble with constituency elections is, zoom in too much and you lose the wood for the trees; zoom out too much and you’ll miss the stampeding herds.

But we have to start somewhere, so let’s start at the local level.

The Gilanis lost ground in Multan.

Ask the Gilani camp why and they’ll point to the ECP. They couldn’t bus people in, they couldn’t set up camps near the polling stations and they were too afraid to brazenly violate the new rules because of all the cameras around — they didn’t want another Waheeda Shah on their hands.

Bottom line, the PPP voter was disenfranchised.

But the other side also suffered the same handicaps. And yet they polled 15,000 more votes than in 2008.

By-elections usually have lower turnouts but there was at least one genuine procedural hiccup in Multan: the voter lists weren’t up to scratch.

Folks turned up to vote at a polling station only to be told their vote was registered at another station. For a constituency like NA-151 with its large number of rural voters, getting the wrong directions over SMS or turning up at the wrong polling station is the difference between voting and not voting.

Even so, that leaves the PPP a significant 13,000 votes short of the elder Gilani’s winning tally of 77,000 in 2008.

Where did the PPP voter go?

First, though, it makes sense to figure out the PPP voter who didn’t bolt — or even newly voted in its favour.

There were the folks who liked the Seraiki province slogan and there were those who loved all the concrete the Gilanis have poured around Multan. Emotionalism and patronage are still draws.

There were the expected loyalists — the biradari voters, though many defied clan diktats, and the minorities — and there were the unexpected voters — Shias liked the original Bosan but when the PML-N threw its weight behind the replacement Bosan, Shias baulked at voting for a guy supported by the party of Rana Sanauallah and his Shia-baiting extremist friends.

But all of that was a bit of a sideshow.

The PPP lost voters and it may have had little to do with the national factors that everyone’s been touting. Or did it?

Yousuf Raza Gilani was known in Multan for his soft touch. He listened to people, he helped them get by, he went to jail for getting them jobs.

But YRG the prime minister was sucked into the prime-ministerial bubble and couldn’t nurture his constituency personally. So he turned to his brother and son and the provincial assemblymen who were elected on his ticket.

The family proved to be a bit of a let down. Rough around the edges, not really committed to the exhausting work of sustaining grassroots ties, they alienated party workers and loyal voters — a dangerous development in a constituency where it’s always been a bit of a tough fight.

Then there was the usual squabbling with the ‘panel’ members — the provincial assemblymen whose constituencies overlap with NA-151.

Sulking because they may not get a party ticket at the next election or angry because they believe they’ve been treated shabbily, they didn’t work hard to pull in votes.

But there was more, and it’s this part that will have sent a chill down the spines of many a PPP ticketholder.

The PPP everyman — the party worker and loyal voter — is unhappy. He wants to know, what have I got in the last four and a half years?

Wait, what about BISP and the money poured down development holes and subsidies for farmers and jobs in the public sector and lucrative state contracts and the fistfuls of rupees thrown around Multan?

Two problems. The constituency grew richer under YRG’s premiership but it didn’t trickle down. The local leader or biradari head pocketed his cut, looked after his immediate circle, and everyone else was left to fend for themselves.

There’s also only so much patronage the state, even a prime minister, can dole out. For every job granted, nine other voters are angry they don’t have one. For every farmer who’s made a packet through inflated support prices, four others are scraping by on subsistence agriculture.

So come by-election time, a chunk of the party workers and loyal voters looked at the PPP and shrugged. That’s a problem sure to be replicated in PPP constituencies across the country.

In south Punjab, on which the party has pinned much hope, there’s a further complicating factor: the Seraiki province mantra has alienated Punjabi- and Urdu-speaking denizens and migrants from upper and central Punjab.

So for the PPP’s rivals, Multan threw up a tantalising formula that could lead to the party’s rout at the general election. There was a strong candidate with no third rival to worry about, pockets of disgruntled PPP voters, angry and fearful anti-PPP voters, and bagsful to spend on the campaign.

And yet, the PPP did win in Multan and 64,000 votes is a decent enough result.

While every politician would love to cruise to victory, he’ll grab a hard-fought victory with both hands too.

So the other lesson from Multan: patronage, emotionalism and entrenched voter networks can still be massaged to eke out constituency victories.

This, then, is the question after Multan: on the continuum between a canter, hard-fought victories and decimation, where did Multan suggest the PPP’s electoral fortunes lie at present?

The PPP optimist will be hoping for a hard-fought victory come the next general election.

But rivals have smelled blood in Multan and may start to believe decimation of the PPP at the next election is a genuine possibility.

Tailpiece: The apology-Gloc deal was supposed to have been fronted by the civilians and blessed by the army behind the scenes. But the long, long meeting at Hina Khar’s residence on the night of July 2-3 which finalised the text of Hillary Clinton’s soft apology and wrapped up a deal whose full dimensions we don’t yet know was presided over by — Gen K himself.

Guess that’s a memo the DPC and the political opposition didn’t get.

The writer is a member of staff.

cyril.a@gmail.com

twitter: @cyalm


Do you have information you wish to share with Dawn.com? You can email our News Desk to share news tips, reports and general feedback. You can also email the Blog Desk if you have an opinion or narrative to share, or reach out to the Special Projects Desk to send us your Photos, or Videos.

More From This Section

Labour wakes up

We can learn from Bangladesh’s example to push for workplace safety.

Comments (11) (Closed)


Nabeel Pervez
Jul 22, 2012 01:23pm
Shame on us as a nation on this win.
NASAH (USA)
Jul 22, 2012 05:15pm
"The rumors of my death have been highly exaggerated" -- Mark Twain
Iqbal
Jul 22, 2012 11:06am
The analysis leaves little to no doubt that the writer represents a particular party. I mean, he has totally ignored the fact Bosan belongs to PTI and we all know that they have gained significant popularity in Pakistan. I am not a big fan of Khan but this by-election indicates that there is change in the air.
KIND
Jul 22, 2012 07:39am
The writer writes what he doesn't want
Toti34
Jul 22, 2012 04:28pm
The difference between democracy and dictatorship (or controlled democracy) is that there is no such thing owning votes. And your reference to 'gullibility of our people' shows your distaste for democracy. May be one should live in Syria to see the difference, where thousands are being killed for wanting a change. In Pakistan it can happen within a few months and that too without any bloodshed and fraud, as election commission is neutral. Personally I do not mind who loses, as long as it is not democracy.
Zero
Jul 22, 2012 11:03am
Winning by a margin of just 4k votes in an area which Gilani literally owns, is NOT a win; it's a wake up call. This tells me that come general elections, saving the historical gullibility of our people, PPP will lose big time!
amerkhan
Jul 22, 2012 06:10am
' all the concrete the Gilanis have poured around Multan'.. . Absolutely hilarious and tragic as well! Yous wit and analysis is matchless. You are the reason why I visit dawn.com every Sunday!
M Rafique
Jul 22, 2012 06:23am
Day by day it becoming harder for the writer to see PPP on political stage.
Toti34
Jul 22, 2012 07:07am
Very well written. What I do not understand is that many journalists were saying that PPP government is sooo unpopular, in fact the most unpopular ever. And yet, it won. Even after 4 years of not delivering much. Living in Germany and depending on media opinions, I can say to media men, what Muhammad Ali, the famous US boxer, said after winning a formidable opponent : Eat your words.
mirza
Jul 22, 2012 02:39pm
People are uneducated and very poor. Gilanis may be despots but they still provide some relief to the poor. The likes of Imran Khan, MQM, PML(N) just talk , and that too nonsense.
Ahsan ali
Jul 22, 2012 01:19pm
Salute to PPP!! IT WON!!! Salute to democracy! they have every right to celebrate...nobody should be able to point any finger now!! Despite all the corruption, unemployment, massacre of country economy, load shedding, law and order havoc...failed foreignpolicies....the people voted for their choice of rulers! These people deserve these rulers!! I think they're IN for another 5 years in the next elections!! Pakistan ka Allah he hafiz!!