No focus on governance

Published Jun 27, 2012 01:02am

COALITION governments are by their very nature messy businesses: junior partners demand their pound of flesh at every turn; pushing through serious reforms is a fraught affair; and the senior coalition partner is stuck walking a tightrope between the legitimate demands of the public and the not-so-legitimate demands of its coalition partners. Having said that, coalitions can and do deliver governance and policies when there is the political will. Unhappily for Pakistan, a new prime minister and a new cabinet have not translated into an iota of political will to try and right the ship of governance and give it any forward momentum. With the addition of 15 new ministers from the PML-Q on Monday, the federal cabinet is within touching distance of the bloated Gilani cabinet. Numbers only tell a part of the story: scroll through the list of cabinet members and their portfolios and there is a distinct sense that merit and aptitude were non-factors in selecting which minister will handle which portfolio. Expecting a coalition disastrously unconcerned with matters of governance for over four years to become a paragon of good governance overnight was perhaps too much. Then again, with a general election around the corner and the country wracked by crises on the economic, security and political fronts, there was some hope that more attention would be paid to delivering on governance promises.

Of course, the motive behind the PPP’s capitulation to the PML-Q’s demands is fairly obvious. In a patronage-driven electoral system where good governance is often a distant concern, the PPP is calculating that the PML-Q parliamentarians elevated to ministerial status will be able to leverage their clout inside the state system to defeat their opponents at the next election. And with Punjab set to be a crucial battleground, the more soldiers on the field the PPP-Q League combine has at the next election, the better its chances of securing re-election. It’s an approach borne out of a paucity of imagination. Arguably, a more competent cabinet in the final stretch would deliver more votes come election time than a patronage system being squeezed for another few drops of support.


Do you have information you wish to share with Dawn.com? You can email our News Desk to share news tips, reports and general feedback. You can also email the Blog Desk if you have an opinion or narrative to share, or reach out to the Special Projects Desk to send us your Photos, or Videos.

More From This Section

Rock and a hard place

The reason why the police turned their ire on journalists as Islamabad descended into chaos is not hard to understand.

Endangered temple

The white stripe on the national flag designed to represent Pakistan’s numerous minority-religion groups is ignored.

Comments (5) (Closed)


Iftikhar Husain
Jun 27, 2012 11:13am
The editorial has given the right direction but how this will give the people the vision not to mistake again and bring the old lot again. That will be a disaster for the country.
I Ahmed
Jun 27, 2012 10:16am
Excellent editorial. Doesn't this lead to the conclusion that a patronage based democratic system is not the solution. Next editorial should highlight what system of elections and democracy Pakistan must have as this one ain't going to work!
M. Asghar
Jun 27, 2012 09:37am
The Editoriam pins down well the utter cynicism of the preseent governamental set up about good govenance , nay, any governace at all, when the country is in a turmoil due to so many unsolved problems.
Muhammad Alvi
Jun 27, 2012 01:05pm
The editorial has correctly identified the problem of politics and governance. The political system in Pakistan is not working. In parliamentry system the executive branch (including the prime minister and president) are elected by the majority party, or a coallition of parties. The coallition parties make deals with each other to share the power and opportunity for corruption. Nobody pays any attention to governance. The parliamentry system of government in Pakistan is totally wrong. Pakistan needs the presidential system, but the politicians do not like it.
Wajid Dhakan
Jun 27, 2012 07:05am
It will be convicteable for PPP to have the coalition govt with the Q govt as it will support in the whole punjab province and easily both parties can hit the N LEAGUE ,, Wajid Dhakan Szabist Larkana