The news from Russia

Published Jun 20, 2012 10:03pm

NEWS is a subjective thing. It is different from fact. Some news is based on a selection of facts, some on selectively ignoring them.

Disinformation is a different genre. It uses half-truths and plain lies to project what passes for news. Indian journalist Syed Mohamed Kazmi is lodged in Delhi’s Tihar Jail awaiting trial for three unending months because he marshalled sacred facts to present events in Syria.

His accounts of the goings-on also in Iran and Lebanon challenged the dominant western storytelling about the chess moves currently under way there. Kazmi’s enviable contacts in the Persian-Arabic speaking region made him asset and villain in rival camps.

Israel and India contrived an untenable terror story involving a mysterious bomb attack on an Israeli car in Delhi. Kazmi was named as an accused, which effectively silenced him as a reporter at a crucial time on the Middle East chessboard. With the Indian reporter out of the frame the Pilger-Fisk battery is left alone to stand up to the Murdochian onslaught prevailing in Syria and elsewhere.

Because news is a subjective thing, Kazmi would be a hero in Russia just as he is something of a villain for Israel and its votaries in India. It is the season of white nights over St Petersburg when the sun hardly gets to go down before it bobs up again.

The Russians are not losing any sleep though — not over the prolonged daylight hours, and not over the political mess the world is wading through. On the contrary, Moscow has taken a surprisingly assertive stand on Syria.

Not that it has not stood up recently on other key issues, namely, Iran, the Nato-led anti-missile defence shield proposed in Europe and over President Vladimir Putin’s recent re-election itself, which the West resented.

It may not be a coincidence that I am thinking of Kazmi in Moscow. His version of events in Syria tallies with the Russian account of the facts from the volatile region.

For a South Asian readership-viewership that is heavily dependent on the BBC-CNN-Fox News-vended information or western wire agencies to glean global events on a regular basis the Russian slant or for that matter the Chinese view of the world almost doesn’t exist.

This is how Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov may have got to take the unusual step to spell out his perspective on Syria in a 3,000-word piece he wrote in The Huffington Post.

Most other foreign ministers would call a simple news conference if they had to clarify a policy matter. But Mr Lavrov perhaps knows that news is a subjective thing and not all journalists, including the most professional ones, would successfully decode much less purvey the nuanced arguments of high-stake diplomacy.

The media has alerted us about Russian warships heading for Syria. That’s an important aspect of the story no doubt. But the cogent narrative of the issue would remain elusive without some important points Mr Lavrov made.

Russia does not support Bashar al-Assad’s regime he wrote. It was for the people to Syria to determine who should rule and how. He makes a strong point against the way the Syrian story has been reported.

“Unfortunately, qualified and honest analysis of developments in Syria and their potential consequences is still in short supply. Quite often it is replaced by primitive images and black-and-white propaganda clichés. For several months major international media outlets have been reproducing reports about the corrupt dictatorial regime ruthlessly suppressing the aspiration of its own people to freedom and democracy,” Mr Lavrov wrote.

“It seems, however, that the authors of those reports did not bother asking themselves how the government could manage to stay in power without public support for more than a year, despite the extensive sanctions imposed by its main economic partners. Why did the majority of people vote for the draft constitution proposed by the authorities? Why, after all, have most Syrian soldiers remained loyal to their commanders? If fear is the only explanation, then why did it fail to help other authoritarian rulers?”

A major sticking point against a more comprehensive global intervention in Syria was rooted in the misappropriation by the West of the terms of the earlier resolution cleared by Russia to deal with Qadhafi’s Libya.

“Unfortunately, the actions undertaken by Nato countries under these resolutions led to their grave violation and support for one of the parties to the civil war, with the goal of ousting the existing regime — damaging in the process the authority of the Security Council.”

The complicated situation in Iraq and the crisis in Afghanistan, which Moscow believes is far from over, are by-products of western zeal to intervene in a hurry. “There are many indications that things are far from being good in Libya after the ousting of Muammar Qadhafi. Instability has spread further to the Sahara and Sahel region, and the situation in Mali was dramatically aggravated.”

Similarly, the possibility of a military strike against Iran should worry the world.

Independent of the Iran tangle, however, Mr Lavrov argues that fuelling intra-Syrian strife could trigger events that would affect the situation in the vast territory surrounding Syria in the most negative way, having a devastating impact on both regional and international security.

“Risk factors include loss of control over the Syrian-Israeli border, a worsening of the situation in Lebanon and other countries in the region, weapons falling into the ‘wrong hands’, including those of terrorist organisations, and, perhaps the most dangerous of all, an aggravation of interfaith tensions and contradictions inside the Islamic world.”

Diplomats don’t trouble trouble till trouble troubles them. Mr Lavrov took a veiled shot at Saudi Arabia for a reason. Respect for human rights, he said, has traditionally been, and continues to be, a major problem for the states of the Middle East.

The good thing about Mr Lavrov’s assertions is that he doesn’t have to worry about getting locked up for flaunting his set of facts as has happened with the hapless Indian journalist.

The writer is Dawn’s correspondent in Delhi.

jawednaqvi@gmail.com


Do you have information you wish to share with Dawn.com? You can email our News Desk to share news tips, reports and general feedback. You can also email the Blog Desk if you have an opinion or narrative to share, or reach out to the Special Projects Desk to send us your Photos, or Videos.

More From This Section

Not on their watch

The political and military leadership knows it can happen again. It knows it can’t stop it from happening again.

Of Cuban tenacity

The phone rang — with good news from Fidel Castro’s land. A new chapter had begun.

Comments (19) Closed




Iftikhar Husain
Jun 21, 2012 11:41am
It is a very balanced article nice to read and admire thank you.
Sid
Jun 21, 2012 11:06am
Mr Naqvi everything you wrote about russia and Syria may be true.It looks like you are not in peace if u do not criticize India.Give us proof to say that the guy who was arrested is not guilty.He was a small time journalist in a urdu press.Show some common sense and come out of conspiracy theories!!
Masroor
Jun 21, 2012 11:14am
subjective or whatever..news are being manufactured! From Pakistan to US to Mongolia....everywhere....
noor wahab
Jun 21, 2012 01:24pm
world of educated people have failed in simple terms to explain the big game of exploitation that
Pradeep
Jun 21, 2012 12:12pm
I request all Journalists not to pronounce a person guilty or innocent and then force public opinion towards it. That’s very biased and I have seen instances where innocent are jailed and guilty are left out free. Kazmi could be guilty or an innocent but declaring him innocent without letting the judicial system finish its proceedings is unacceptable. Let the legal system first finish its job and then you can unleash your wrath.
Nano Thermite
Jun 21, 2012 07:59pm
very good article - analytical and informative. Thank you.
Atis
Jun 21, 2012 02:41pm
A correct analysis of the situation in Syria, no doubt!
PNP
Jun 21, 2012 10:05pm
An article is 'balanced' when both sides' viewpoints are analysed and given equal space, something Mr. Naqvi is not known for.
Amir
Jun 21, 2012 07:30pm
Pakistan is located between South Arabia and Eastern Persia and not in South Asia. Keeping this reality in mind, Russians will be better of developing distinctive policies toward this region separate from South Asian region encompassing 2 major underdeveloped countries Afghanistan and India .
Indian Muslim
Jun 21, 2012 07:29pm
What about " Innocent til proved otherwise" ? i mean he is just an accused, nothing is proven against him, he can ran for any election in India there are hundreds if not thousands accused elected official in India and if you look at the history of conviction in India may be he will be exonerated. Anyway reporters shall be supported more vigorously at this particular time as their are very high chances that people in power may try to silence the daring reporter with theses sort of charges. well the business of reporting is as such that you may have contact with every element of society. so we should support the reporter (media) as it is the fourth pillar of democracy. Off course if convicted he shall be treated accordingly but until convicted he is innocent
Avinash
Jun 21, 2012 05:28pm
A nice conspiracy theory!!
DeepIndia
Jun 21, 2012 06:32am
What? Confused. I think I need to take reading comprehension lessons.
caz
Jun 21, 2012 06:26pm
Russia Today (RT) and Press TV channels must be made available in South Asia.
Cyrus Howell
Jun 21, 2012 07:37am
"This is likely to be administered for a course of years and then end in despotism... when the people shall become so corrupted as to need despotic government, being incapable of any other." -- Benjamin Franklin (1706-1790)
Mahavir
Jun 21, 2012 03:26pm
"NEWS is a subjective thing. It is different from fact. Some news is based on a selection of facts, some on selectively ignoring them." Javedj and you have mastered the art.
BNS
Jun 21, 2012 10:52pm
Thanks Jawed. Good info. Lets hope Kazmi gets justice,
Mustafa Razavi
Jun 22, 2012 01:17am
@Pradeep That itself depends on how much stock do you put in the legal system in question. Can a Muslim get a fair trial in India? particularly if he is accused of of anti-state activity? After all we are talking about a judicial system which has declared Narindra Modi an innocent man. @Sid In civilized world, you have to prove guilt not innocence.
AHC
Jun 22, 2012 08:48am
A thought provoking critique. The article adds new dimensions to the series of upheavals that have and are taking place in the Middle East. The world has become a global village and the lead players in order to maintain their dominance poke noses in to others' matters. Mr. Jawed has produced an excellent critique that lists out the major stake holders and the role media is playing today, be it US, UK, India or Pakistan. With a plethora of scandals of media personnel erupting every other day, it becomes the responsibility of an upright, duty-bound and balanced media person (especially a journalist) to muster facts, possibilities, historical references and conjectures about future events to enlighten the world with listing all the predictable future happenings. Mr. jawed has produced a well organised script. It doesn't only help us in broadening our mental horizons but gauging the global politics. As for those who think that it's a conspiracy theory, it needs to be understood by the example of a soldier whose duty is to protect and defend his land so analogically it becomes an obligation of a journalist to explore the unexplored through knowledge, prudence, brainstorming and a sense of critique. Indeed a good job Mr. Jawed. Bravo Zulu!
AHC
Jun 22, 2012 09:32am
A thought provoking critique. The article adds new dimensions to the series of upheavals that have and are taking place in the Middle East. The world has become a global village and the lead players in order to maintain their dominance poke noses in to others' matters. Mr. Jawed has produced an excellent critique that lists out the major stake holders and the role media is playing today, be it US, UK, India or Pakistan. With a plethora of scandals of media personnel erupting every other day, it becomes the responsibility of an upright, duty-bound and balanced media person (especially a journalist) to muster facts, possibilities, historical references and conjectures about future events to enlighten the world with listing all the predictable future happenings. Mr. jawed has produced a well organised script. It doesn't only help us in broadening our mental horizons but gauging the global politics. As for those who think that it's a conspiracy theory, it needs to be understood by the example of a soldier whose duty is to protect and defend his land so analogically it becomes an obligation of a journalist to explore the unexplored through knowledge, prudence, brainstorming and a sense of critique.