Kohistan women

Published Jun 08, 2012 08:05pm

THERE are lessons to be learned from the furore over the case of five women who were apparently not, in fact, killed in Kohistan for allegedly singing and clapping in male company. The story was replete with red flags that should have prevented media outlets from jumping to the conclusions that they did. For one, the village in question is incredibly remote and quite inaccessible to journalists. Second, the video on which the claims were based raises obvious questions and could just as easily have been edited to tell a certain story. In no frame are the men and women seen together, and even their backdrops seem different. Based on such flimsy evidence, sections of the media then launched a campaign backed by the unverified testimony of one set of brothers.

This is admittedly tricky ground for the Pakistani media. Discrimination and violence against women are genuine problems in the country. But the fact that abuses do take place, and the importance of highlighting women’s rights issues, should not become an excuse to judge these stories by lower standards than others. There is also the problem of technology. Cellphone video recordings, YouTube, Facebook and Twitter can bring to light abuses that the media might not otherwise have access to. But the temptation to accept these sources at face value only means that scrutinising them is critical. In fact, elements of the story still remain unclear — only two of the five women have been seen in person by the delegation sent by the Supreme Court, and reports still differ on such details as when the video was made and whether or not a jirga did condemn the women to death. This was a story that required far more balanced coverage than it received.


Do you have information you wish to share with Dawn.com? You can email our News Desk to share news tips, reports and general feedback. You can also email the Blog Desk if you have an opinion or narrative to share, or reach out to the Special Projects Desk to send us your Photos, or Videos.

More From This Section

Rock and a hard place

The reason why the police turned their ire on journalists as Islamabad descended into chaos is not hard to understand.

Endangered temple

The white stripe on the national flag designed to represent Pakistan’s numerous minority-religion groups is ignored.

Comments (3) (Closed)


NASAH (USA)
Jun 09, 2012 03:05pm
Yet it is better for the media to be extra watchful for such crimes to occur than to be complacent that it could not happen. We are so glad such a horrendous thing did not happen -- thanks to the media vigilance.
Brijesh
Jun 09, 2012 03:29am
Whatever be the reality, Indians and Pakistanis treat their women poorly. Sorry state of affairs I tell you.
ASHRAF JAFRANY
Jun 09, 2012 09:00am
Very true. This is the need of hour to scrutinize the news first then let it be on aired. The main reason is that our so called journalists do not want to rely on research and authenticated news they just rely on news stories made in drawing rooms. The said episode of Kohistan women is one of the many example . What does it need is to look into the news verify it and then it should be telecast ed . This is all due to mushroom growth development of news channel having no experienced and qualified man power in the shape of sophisticated journalistic community. In addition to this it has been seen that some of tv reporters are grabbing money by making such type of news stuff. Moreover the certain faction of media does favor and high light the issue which is directly related to their relatives or political affiliation. It does not mean that we have many news channels and we are having independent media but the more the numbers of channels the more they are providing less balanced coverage .