KPK’s drive for justice

Updated Aug 29, 2013 04:40pm
A civil judge conducts proceedings in the first mobile court in Pakistan - Photo by AFP
A civil judge conducts proceedings in the first mobile court in Pakistan - Photo by AFP
A Pakistani policemen stands guard beside the first mobile court  in Pakistan - Photo by AFP
A Pakistani policemen stands guard beside the first mobile court in Pakistan - Photo by AFP
People gathered outside the first mobile court in Pakistan - Photo by AFP
People gathered outside the first mobile court in Pakistan - Photo by AFP
Policemen stand guard outside the first mobile court in Pakistan's KPK province - Photo by AFP
Policemen stand guard outside the first mobile court in Pakistan's KPK province - Photo by AFP
First mobile court designed to go directly to the people, resolving their daily disputes in some of the most remote and dangerous parts of the country - Photo by AFP
First mobile court designed to go directly to the people, resolving their daily disputes in some of the most remote and dangerous parts of the country - Photo by AFP

PESHAWAR: Sweat poured down Judge Fazal Wadood’s back as he sat perched behind a desk inside the custom-built green bus court.

The latest weapon in Pakistan’s battle against a creaking judicial system, the $98,000 mobile court allows Judge Wadood to preside over cases and disputes that have dragged on for years because of the slow grinding process involved in regular courts.

The situation has helped build frustration among the people and increased calls for Islamic sharia law at the government’s expense.

The bus has been set up by the high court in the northwestern Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KPK) province.

Boasting a portrait of Pakistan's founding father Muhammad Ali Jinnah, the bus is designed to go directly to the people, resolving their daily disputes in some of the most remote and dangerous parts of the country.

Part of a $15 million project, with 25 per cent financed by the government in northwest of Pakistan and the rest by international donors, the mobile court aims to strengthen both the present judicial system and state institutions.

Musarat Shah, a 72-year-old widower locked in a five-year land dispute, was one of the first on board the bus, which has the white crescent and star of the Pakistani flag emblazoned on its side.

“Justice delayed is justice denied,” said Shah, furious with the slow pace of the regular court system. “Multiple commissions were held. One commission finished and demanded another commission, and it was taking us nowhere.”

After hearing her case, Judge Wadood summoned a group of mediators who agreed to go off and inspect her land, before setting another hearing in a week's time.

Marc-Andre Franche, the head of UNDP in Pakistan, stated that the mobile court, which is an attempt at strengthening the judicial system, was one of the main ways to counter the influence of non-state actors.

Eight judges and 18 lawyers have been trained in conflict resolution to find quick solutions in simple cases that risk dragging on for years, clogging up the judicial system.

On its first one day, with the bus stationary in a car park in the Hayatabad suburb of Peshawar, Wadood together with a registrar and stenographer tapping away on a laptop, handled nearly 30 cases.

Chairman of the arbitration council, Mohammad Osman Khan, says the work consists of speedy mediation between parties in different conflicts normally faced in daily life, such as property battles, family problems and others.

However, the mobile court faces certain challenges in its path to success, which will help authorities determine whether it is worth rolling out further courtroom buses.

One of the major challenges is the inbred jirga system, which consists of traditional gatherings of tribal elders who typically mediate similar disputes at a local level.

Judgments passed at such gatherings by the elders are considered law in the tribal area.

Human rights organisations criticise their decisions as arbitrary.

The director of the judicial academy in Peshawar, Hayat Ali Shah, believes that the two systems can coexist.

“A civil litigation in KPK comes to the court only when the jirga and others fail. So hopefully there will be no competition,” Shah said.

He was hopeful the mobile initiative would be effective.

Although, it remains unclear how many villagers will opt for the mobile court rather than the traditional jirga system.

Security is another challenge that is being faced at present by the mobile court. So far, its work is limited to Peshawar’s suburbs. It is followed by an armed police escort.

The authorities are trying to agree on extra security precautions for when the bus travels to more dangerous parts of the northwest, away from the heavily protected city of Peshawar.

But Judge Wadood is not afraid of death. He feels providing justice to the common man is more important than worrying about safety.

“Such problems are everywhere,” he said, with regards to situations in different cities. “We don’t fear working here or there.”


Do you have information you wish to share with Dawn.com? You can email our News Desk to share news tips, reports and general feedback. You can also email the Blog Desk if you have an opinion or narrative to share, or reach out to the Special Projects Desk to send us your Photos, or Videos.

More From This Section

Comments (16) Closed


khanm
Aug 29, 2013 05:38pm

justice is suppose to be blind folded.... i sincerely hope it is not in the driving seat

Jawaad Aslam
Aug 29, 2013 05:51pm

Great work PTI government. This is what people expect from you. Start working... stop protesting. Prove yourself that you are the best

Zahir
Aug 29, 2013 06:49pm

Good Initiative. They should also run mobile clinics on similar busses.

H L
Aug 29, 2013 08:11pm

Huge take on it. But very impressive and courageous step. Indeed not a better time for its implementation and testing. Wish you best of luck.

SK
Aug 29, 2013 09:48pm

Great initiative! Hope it is successful.

Azam
Aug 30, 2013 01:43am

Excellent work PTI. Perhaps some media channel should provide the coverage of mobile court in action. That way we can receive a direct feedback of public response. Well done PTI, keep up the good work.

SMN
Aug 30, 2013 04:56am

Not going to make any dent. Make lower judiciary accountable for dragging cases. Increase judges and penalties.

waqas manzoor
Aug 30, 2013 10:53am

Really inspiring and a true game changer. Good work PTI, we hope for more innovative solutions from your midst.

munsif
Aug 30, 2013 11:34am

PTI must introduce good governance and management of case documents in courts.

If interested a special story about courts in sindh is available with me.

Syed Usman
Aug 30, 2013 12:16pm

nice step of PTI in KPK....

msa
Aug 30, 2013 12:22pm

This mobile court system is working in the USA since hundred of years ago and once judges used to travel on horses from one place to another and dispensed the justice. Great step forward.

azmat
Aug 30, 2013 02:42pm

Whoever has written this peice seems to have very little knowledge of KPK. All of KPK is not run by "tribal elders" and "tribal jirgas". If that was the case then courts would not have been overflowing with cases. People often confuse "tribal areas" with KPK which is not the case. The 7 Tribal areas are part of FATA which is Federellay Administered Tribal Areas and KPK govt has nothing to do with it. Tribal Jirga System is a law in its own right in FATA and pakistani legal system has very limited application in those areas- hence its popularity. Whereas in KPK, cases decided by the "local jirgas" have no legal standing in the eye of the law

ali
Aug 30, 2013 03:59pm

Good work There was no other way to go to more remote areas to provide quick justice..However more police protection with trained officers is need to make this system successful

Ariba
Aug 30, 2013 08:41pm

@msa: Can you tell which cities & states is this happening in?

aamir
Aug 31, 2013 08:52am

Dr Shakeel afridi 's release seems to be the very act of such mobile justice...

Imran
Aug 31, 2013 09:17pm

Great to hear,can we have more detail on this