FROM an air force pilot to a royal 30-year furlough in the presidential palace to an accused in a cage, Hosni Mubarak is now out of prison. He could have been a free man but for the Egyptian prime minister, who, using his emergency powers, ordered that the former dictator be kept under house arrest. The change in Mr Mubarak’s fortunes is as much amazing as it is ironic. What greater irony could there be in the generals’ two hare-brained decisions? One takes a former dictator out of prison; the other sends a democratically elected president to jail? No one ever voted for Mr Mubarak as president during his three-decade stay in Kasr Gomhouria where he lived in royal splendour, while the whereabouts of Mohamed Morsi, for whom millions of Egyptians voted, remain known only to his captors. Mr Mubarak at least had the benefit of an open trial; Mr Morsi doesn’t have even that. Mr Mubarak still has to face one charge — the killing of hundreds of pro-democracy protesters. Mr Morsi, on the other hand, handled the demonstrators with considerably less force.

The Arab Spring has now become a chilly winter, with democracy trying to find a warm place for itself. What began as a struggle for democratic rights has channelled into hideous zones. Syria has become a sectarian battleground, while in Egypt the army is slaughtering citizens demanding a return to the Arab Spring’s moral fibre. The generals have messed up. Using Mr Morsi’s mistakes as a pretext, they have usurped power, and the way things are going it is difficult to see how Egypt can return to democracy. The saner way out for the generals is to seek a negotiated settlement with all political parties, halt brutal crackdowns and announce an election date.


Do you have information you wish to share with Dawn.com? You can email our News Desk to share news tips, reports and general feedback. You can also email the Blog Desk if you have an opinion or narrative to share, or reach out to the Special Projects Desk to send us your Photos, or Videos.

More From This Section

Swiss talks

The Swiss envoy to Pakistan has reportedly said the talks are “just a technical meeting” to avoid double taxation.

Need for precaution

There were over 30 dengue-related deaths in Sindh last year, while over 6,000 people tested positive.

Most Popular

Comments (1) (Closed)


ROHIT PANDEY
Aug 25, 2013 12:23am

Hosni Mubarak,Saddam Hussein's Baa'th Party as well as Assad's regime Baa'th Party again..had one very solid virtue behind them-they were SECULAR.

The Arab-Muslim population given a chance to vote,vote in the most regressive elements possible with an Islamist-theocratic bend of mind-for the population is of that variety and the message resonates with them.

What is happening in Syria today happened in Algeria and is happening in one form or other in Turkey,Tunisia and of course, Iran with it's decades-old Islamic "revolution".

Better nothing said about Pakistan and Gen.Zia ul Haq..or Liaqat Ali Khan and this and that..

Unless Muslims learn to shed this fascination for theocracy-advocated politics nothing much is going to happen in the Muslim world..just chaos and turmoil of one variety or another.

When are Muslims to learn the value of sound modern education,science and technology enterprise and economics and not sterile theocratic politics?

To top it all,the narration of Indian history is that Islam provided a scaffolding for Indian-Hindu civilization...at least,that is what I understand is being taught it Pakistani schools?

Within just six decades or so of parting ways...Islamic Pakistan is gripped with turmoil of monumental proportions-where did that scaffolding which sustained civilization in India disappear,I wonder???