KP: appointments and merit

Updated Aug 09, 2013 04:41am

THIS is in response to reports (July 28) wherein there is a tussle among Nowshera lawyers over the appointment of advocate-general and additional AGs in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.

Since the PTI has taken charge of the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa government, there are lawyers who hope to become advocate-general, additional advocate-general and deputy advocate-general.

In the recent past, if we look at the MMA and ANP governments, these posts were given to advocates having political affiliations with the party which was governing Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.

Merit and qualifications were totally ignored while appointing people for these posts. Recently the chief justice of the Peshawar High Court, Justice Dost Muhammad Khan, has categorically asked the government to ensure that appointments for AG and additional AGs should be made on merit. He has said that this is keeping in view what happened in the past.

The constitutional provision relating to the appointment of advocate-general is there. It says that a person who is ‘qualified as a judge of the high court’ shall be appointed an advocate-general.

The interesting aspect of the case is that the constitution (Article 144) speaks about the qualification of the advocate-general but it nowhere speaks regarding the disqualification of the advocate-general. This is also fortified by the Supreme Court in one of its judgments.

Another important issue is that there is no constitutional provision regarding the appointment of additional AGs and deputy AGs and there is no statutory law in this regard.

So, the entire discretion is left on the sweet will of the government which tries its best to appoint its near and dear ones for these key posts, which ultimately results in the poor performance by law officers in the province.

It is time qualified and capable persons were appointed for the said posts. Furthermore, the PTI, before and after the general elections, promised to follow merit and bring about a change. If slogans are not transformed into action, it will result in the collapse of the PTI in the province.

If the PTI really wants this province as a role model for the country, nepotism and favoritism should be discouraged.

The provincial assembly must formulate and promulgate laws regarding the strict criteria for appointments for these key posts and should also prescribe for their disqualification.

Interestingly, in the recent past, during the ANP government, lawyers who didn’t have licences for practising at the high court were also appointed to these posts. This created distrust not only in the bar but also in the bench.

I suggest written test and interviews should be held for appointments for additional and deputy AGs. Competent individuals can be appointed only if a board of competent lawyers and retired and sitting judges of the superior judiciary is constituted for conducting interviews to ensure that merit is being observed.

NASIR KAMAL YOUSAFZAI
(Advocate)
Mardan


Do you have information you wish to share with Dawn.com? You can email our News Desk to share news tips, reports and general feedback. You can also email the Blog Desk if you have an opinion or narrative to share, or reach out to the Special Projects Desk to send us your Photos, or Videos.

More From This Section

Collective will

LATELY there has been an increasing clatter in the media and social circles about how to face terrorism and Indian...

Port Qasim

IN every government organisation, there is a facility called extraordinary leave and ex-Pakistan leave, which is...

Killing houbara

ONLY this year a courageous and conscientious game warden in Balochistan, Jaffar Baloch, blew the whistle on the...

Comments (2) Closed




M aslam
Aug 09, 2013 07:20pm

Mr. Nasir Do your realy believe that PTI intention is to make KPK a role model? Please wake up and come out of fools paradise. All merit and capabilities lies in the dear ones of IK or provincial leadership and they have to select all key posts among these capable people. All other people who are not part of PTI are corrupt and incapable people so dont accept any thing good from PTI. Its leader is borne and raised in such a beghairat family that they never taught him meaning of sharmnak and Khan sahib come to know first time in his life that sharmnak is a "Gali". So do you still think that he can deliver anything good for the nation?

Ma
Aug 11, 2013 03:54am

@M aslam: Whatever you say, I think IK is much much better than these corrupt and incompetent people we have and had in power.