WASHINGTON, Sept 30: Israel is quietly
lobbying to allow international transfer of nuclear technology to the countries
that are regarded as nuclear weapon states but have not yet signed the
Non-Proliferation Treaty, The Washington Post reported on Sunday.
Currently, three countries — India, Pakistan and Israel — fall in this category
but the Israeli proposal will only benefit India and Israel while Pakistan is
left out of this plan because of its alleged proliferation records.
The 45-nation Nuclear Suppliers Group does not allow trade with countries that
have not signed the NPT. Thus countries such as India, Israel and Pakistan are
prohibited from participating in international nuclear trade, including buying
reactors, uranium fuel or yellowcake.
But the United States, which has signed an agreement for sharing nuclear
technology with India, is lobbying the NSG to exempt New Delhi from its
restrictions. The Post, however, noted that the Israeli move may complicate the
Bush administration’s efforts to win an exemption for India to engage in such
trade. The administration still faces a strong opposition from the anti-nuclear
lobbies as it pushes to clear the final hurdles blocking the groundbreaking
agreement with India.
Using the Israeli proposal as an example, the opponents of the Indo-US nuclear
deal can argue that any exception to the NPT restriction may open the gate to
proliferation as other non-recognised nuclear states may also demand acceptance.
Documents outlining Israel’s proposal were distributed among the NSG members in
March and have circulated on Capitol Hill in Washington in recent days.
The Israeli plan offers 12 criteria for allowing nuclear trade with non-treaty
states, including one that hints at Israel’s status as an undeclared nuclear
weapons state: A state should be allowed to engage in nuclear trade if it
applies “stringent physical protection, control and accountancy measures to all
nuclear weapons, nuclear facilities, source material and special nuclear
material in its territory.”
Daryl G. Kimball, executive director of the Arms Control Association in
Washington, said the Israeli document could affect the debate over India. “The
dynamics at the NSG are that no country wants to stand in the way of the largest
country, India, and the most powerful country, the US,” he said.