Low Graphics Site
White bar
.: Latest News :. .: News in Pictures :.
Dawn e-paper
Daily SectionMarker

Misc SectionMarker

Horoscope Recipes Weekly SectionMarker

Weekly SectionMarker



Pakistan's Internet Magazine
Herald
Dawn GroupMarker

Archive, Search, Feedback & HelpMarker

Weather

FrontPage National International Local Business KSE Forex Sports Editorial Opinion Letters Features Today's Cartoon TV Guide Cowasjee Ayaz Irfan Hussain Jawed Naqvi Review Dawn Magazine Young World Images Dawn Group Subscription To Advertise

DINA
DAWN - the Internet Edition


May 21, 2007 Monday Jamadi-ul-Awwal 04, 1428


Editorial


Initiating public-private partnership
For better healthcare
The KWSB in trouble
Making inroads into Europe



Initiating public-private partnership


DEVIATING from its past practice, the Central Development Working Party (CDWP) of the Planning Commission last week approved of four private sector projects. These will be co-funded by the public sector to set up common facility centres for industrial product development and for commercial and foundry services. Earlier, the CDWP’s mandate was restricted to the scrutiny of public sector projects though state-run corporations could enter into joint ventures with the private sector. These approvals indicate that the official policy of public-private partnership is now being extended to the planning and implementation levels. One of the approved projects is a foundry service centre at Lahore for dye-making, moulding, material testing and training. The estimated cost of the project at Rs195 million will be shared on an equal basis by the local chamber which will provide Rs500 million for the purchase of the required land. The CDWP also cleared a common facility project for product development in Gujranwala at an estimated cost of Rs98.7 million. Sialkot will have a product design centre for sports goods and a business and commerce centre for industrial development.

There can be no two opinions about the need for public-private sector partnership or the choice of projects — in this case, a common facility for industrial and commercial pursuits. But without going into the merit of the CDWP decisions, it may be argued that caution has to be exercised in selecting joint venture sponsors to discourage official patronage. The future of public and private sector partnership, for which huge potential exists, because of excess money in the market seeking productive investment, would depend on the success of the schemes initially launched. The efforts being made in developing models of public-private sector partnerships should not go waste. At its meeting on Thursday, the CDWP approved 39 development projects estimated to cost Rs11.7 billion with the top priority going to physical infrastructure followed by the social sector. An important decision taken by the CDWP is to send the project for resettlement action plan for Mirani Dam at an enhanced cost of Rs1.84 billion to the National Economic Council for approval. The National Rural Support Programme has been sponsored to help Balochistan reassess the cost of land, buildings, trees, etc to compensate the affected people.

In the case of dams built earlier, the displaced persons were not fully compensated and many were provided no relief despite a compensation package. It has led to widespread criticism that the mega projects benefit one section of the people by destroying hearths and homes and deprive others of their livelihood. This calls for not only a fair compensation package but the strict implementation of the action plan. The cost of the resettlement plan has gone up because the height of the Mirani Dam has been increased by 20 feet. Unfortunately, cost overruns are becoming quite a common practice for a variety of reasons, including faulty project planning and designing, implementation gaps and weak monitoring. There is also a lack of inter-sectoral harmony which gives rise to a situation like critical power shortage. Whether it is project planning and designing or development strategy, there is much room for improvement. One way to make up for such deficiencies is greater public-private partnership — joint sponsorship of projects but under private management.

Top



For better healthcare


IT IS unrealistic to expect the president’s Primary Health Care Initiative, which is designed to provide relief to the people, especially in the rural areas, to radically change the state of the health sector in Pakistan. The federal government, which has launched the programme, is, however, optimistic that this initiative will resolve many of the problems faced by the impoverished sections of society in obtaining medical care. Whatever little that has been disclosed about the main features of this programme creates some scepticism about its financial viability and sustainability. It is like a pilot project — 10 districts in Sindh, seven in the NWFP and some in the other two provinces have been selected. It will centre round the basic health units in the selected districts that will be upgraded, and doctors and paramedics are being appointed on special pay scales. In some cases they will have transport facilities and so on. The health units will be computerised and equipped with other modern facilities. All this will be on a three-year contract and will cost Rs10 billion in Sindh. It is plain that simply pumping in massive funds will not improve healthcare. The amount allocated for Sindh is double the total health expenditure in the revenue budget of the province for a year.

It is known that the health sector in the rural areas has been suffering from many weaknesses, the shortage of funds being only one of them. A high rate of absenteeism of staff, non-availability of drugs and non-functioning health facilities have rendered the health delivery system in the public sector ineffective. The lack of commitment of the health professionals posted in rural areas — many of them living in the cities and visiting their places of work once in a while — and their poor knowledge also contribute to the falling standards. There is no indication that these problems are being tackled. The infusion of more funds without any monitoring may lead to a rise in corruption and fail to provide any benefit to the people. For the project to be sustainable, it is essential that it be integrated into the mainstream health delivery system, or else it will be discontinued whenever the government so desires.

Top



The KWSB in trouble


THINGS have never been good at the Karachi Water and Sewerage Board, but a newspaper report on Wednesday showed just how bad they are. The utility is said to be close to bankruptcy because of its inability to collect bills and corruption in its revenue department. These shocking disclosures need to be probed and drastic corrective action taken. The KWSB has been plagued by mismanagement problems for years, including its chronic failure to collect dues from individuals as well as government organisations. A report in March showed that the KWSB was Rs30 billion in debt. A month later, another report stated that the utility’s expenditure was Rs4.5 billion while its revenue collection was only Rs2.7 billion. These are depressing figures, made more so by the fact that water shortage in the city is a perennial problem. It doesn’t help matters that around 30 per cent of the city’s water supply is wasted, either because of faulty or leaking pipelines or because of theft. Then there are management problems plaguing the utility; it is overstaffed but needs more technically qualified staff to deal with problems. No wonder the KWSB is in such financial straits.

Last month, the city nazim said that he would put into place a system whereby Union Councils would be responsible for collecting the monthly water bills from the residents of their areas. The KWSB would then give 20 per cent of the collected revenue to the Union Councils and five per cent to the Town Council as a “commission”. The utility must also try to recover the whopping six billion rupees owed to it by organisations like CAA, KPT, the KESC and other government departments and agencies that have not paid their dues for many years. The utility too needs a major overhaul, including downsizing of staff and repair of the existing pipelines which must be initiated at the earliest.

Top



Making inroads into Europe


By Aijaz Zaka Syed

“WHAT is El Emara?” asks my Belarusian friend and journalist with a beatific smile that never seems to touch his deep-set, sad blue eyes. Andrej Dynko has had a far from pleasant experience in his native Belarus. He had to spend some time in his country’s notorious prisons for hurling too many uncomfortable questions at the powers that be. That hasn’t stopped him from coming up with more questions though.

We are taking a late evening stroll along the sleepy boulevard next to our hotel in Brussels. It’s half past eight. Yet the sun doesn’t appear to have gone home. There is so much light it looks as if it’s still five in the evening. And there’s a reinvigorating nip in the pleasantly caressing, fragrant air. Having recently spent a couple of weeks back home in a typical Indian summer, it is refreshing to be in Brussels.

The city is home to the headquarters of the European Union, the powerful economic club of 27 nations and the world’s biggest free trade zone. Dynko, who edits a political weekly Nasha Niva, is visiting Brussels like me in connection with the EU’s Lorenzo Natali Journalism Prize ceremony. He obviously thinks coming from the Middle East I could have the answer to his query.

Unfortunately, yours truly is as familiar with the glory of the Arabic language as Bush had been with Musharraf and Vajpayee before his election by the US Supreme Court.

Which is a real disgrace. Having lived and worked in Dubai for years, one should be ashamed of oneself if one’s familiarity with the Arabs and their rich language and culture doesn’t go beyond the regulation shawarma, sheesha, desert safaris and a mindless emphasis on ‘khallas’ and ‘maafi mushkil’.

The trouble is, you may live and work in the UAE for years without ever really bothering or requiring to learn the local language. Which is what most expatriates from India, Pakistan and the West do. They live, work and move often all their lives in the limited spheres of their communities, without ever trying to understand the host country or society.

This says something about this great country and its amazing people, especially their

tradition of tolerance and

respect towards guests and guest workers.

Returning to Brussels, I told Dynko that El Emara was perhaps an improvisation on Amara, a common Arab and Muslim female name. And in this Brussels neighbourhood, from where the EU parliament and headquarters are only a stone’s throw away, you come across hundreds of Arab and Muslim sounding names of cafes, shops and fast food joints.

Watching roadside cafes with animatedly chatting North African Arabs enjoying their steaming Turkish coffee or kebab, you would think you have stepped back in time or landed in Cairo or Casablanca thanks to your pilot’s error of judgment.

Indian and Pakistani takeaways greet you as soon as you step out of Brussels’ Midi Station, where our high speed train had taken us, promising you ‘Islamic’ food. My apprehensions about halal food had been clearly far from justified. Unlike the rest of Europe, this great city steeped in history and tradition somehow managed to escape the destruction of the two World Wars thanks to Belgian leaders’ clever diplomacy and business sense.

Having been repeatedly invaded by almost all its big neighbours, especially by the French, the Belgians have over the centuries mastered the fine art of diplomacy and political tightrope walking.

Which is perhaps why Brussels has for over the past century or so remained the economic and political hub of Europe. The birth and success of the European Community and later the EU have only ensured and emphasised this unchallenged preeminence of Brussels.

Not for nothing is Brussels considered Europe’s heart. And the large Arab and Muslim community in Belgium, especially in Brussels, is working hard to win it over. There are more than 200,000 Muslims in Brussels alone, a city of one million people who appear to be remarkably at peace with themselves and their incredibly serene

city.

From flight and train attendants of North African descent to hotel receptionists of South Asian origin, the Muslims are everywhere. And there are plenty of headscarves too.

If you thought the 9/11 events and Bush’s war on Muslims have forced the believers to lie low or recede to the margins of European society, think again.

Far from retiring to the oblivion of their ghettos, Arabs and Muslims form a healthy part of the mainstream and host societies in this part of the world. At the same time, they are comfortable with their religious and cultural identity.

And it’s a proud and assertive Islam that continues to spread its wings, constantly conquering new territory in what is considered the citadel of Christian Europe. The Muslims, after Christians, are already the largest religious community and Islam is the fastest growing faith across Europe. No wonder Pope Benedict XVI is getting increasingly concerned over the changing religious profile of the continent and his flock.

But whether Europeans love or hate Muslims, they are there to stay and the hosts can do little about it. Besides, if the Muslims and other immigrants continue to pour into Europe in droves looking for jobs and a better life, the aging Europe too needs the young arrivals.

Not only is the continent not getting any younger, constantly falling birth rates in the indigenous, Caucasian populations pose a serious challenge to the continent’s future. The immigrants fill this vacuum. So this is a mutually benefiting, win-win relationship.

But it would be a disservice to countries like Belgium if you don’t recognise the fact that they have gone out of their way to welcome the never-ending stream of visitors.

Although Belgium doesn’t have an awfully good record in Africa in its colonies like Congo, it hasn’t been bad to Arab and Muslim immigrants. It wooed hundreds of thousands of North African Arabs and Muslims after the Second World War to work in its coalmines.

The present generation of Arabs and Muslims in Belgium are mostly the children of those miners. Significantly, instead of forcing their own culture and ethos on the new arrivals, the Belgians have allowed them to live and flourish in their own space retaining their distinct identity. It’s this approach to integration that is at the heart of the EU experiment.

As a result, the modern Belgian Arabs and Muslims are equally at ease with both Arabic, the language of their forefathers, and Flemish, the language of the country of their choice. So contrary to what Kipling warned, the East and West not only meet in modern Europe but also appear to be enjoying the encounter.And just as the large expatriate community in the UAE and other Middle Eastern countries has played a decisive role in building their host countries, Arabs and Muslims can proudly claim they have a stake in the progress and development of Europe, especially states like Belgium, France and Germany, the original architects of the EU. If Belgium and France are home to the Arabs, Germany hosts a huge community of Turkish Muslims.

It’s often noted with regret by Muslim historians that Europe would have been part of the Muslim world if only the Turks had persisted in their siege of Vienna in the 16th century. The powerful Ottoman army had swept through the Balkans, Greece and Asia Minor to reach Vienna by 1529. The long siege of Vienna, the gateway to Europe, however failed to open the way for Islam. The Turks returned in 1683, under the leadership of Mustafa Pasha, to knock at the gate of Vienna once again.

The second attempt too failed to succeed despite the perseverance and huge losses suffered by the Turks. The Muslim armies were faced with an impregnable wall of resistance largely built by Pope Innocent XI. The Pope managed to unite Christian Europe against the “infidels” in the name of God and the survival of Christendom.

As a result, the Muslim armies were forced to retreat from Vienna once again. The Ottoman tide turned at the gates of Vienna and receded gradually, beginning its long withdrawal through the Balkans and Greece into Asia Minor over the next two centuries.But, you know, history has an annoying habit of repeating itself. For what the Turks failed to accomplish four centuries ago — conquer Europe — by force appears possible today. The Muslims are winning Europe, not by force as the Ottoman caliphate had repeatedly sought to do and failed. The once all-white, all-Christian continent is being changed from within.

The Europe that steeled itself against the onslaught of invading Turkish armies four centuries ago is opening itself to the soft power of Islam. The continent that once proudly stood its ground in the face of the legendary Muslim firepower has submitted itself to Islam’s power of persuasion.

Never underestimate the power of faith.

The writer is a Dubai-based journalist.

aijazsyed@khaleejtimes.com


Top



Top of Page





Seprater
Contributions
Privacy Policy
© DAWN Group of Newspapers, 2007